On April 11, 1970, three astronauts set off on what was meant to be a historic mission to the moon. Jim Lovell, Jack Swigert, and Fred Haise launched from Kennedy Space Center aboard Apollo 13, ready to push the boundaries of human exploration. But what followed was nothing short of a nightmare that would captivate the world—an explosion crippled their spacecraft, leaving them stranded 200,000 miles from Earth. What unfolded next was a dramatic rescue mission, one of the most gripping stories in the history of space exploration.
This story of survival and ingenuity has been retold several times, including in the 1995 blockbuster film Apollo 13, which has become iconic. But before this realistic and highly praised adaptation, there was another film that told the Apollo 13 story—Houston, We’ve Got a Problem—which deviated so far from the truth it might as well have been a work of fiction. In fact, the first attempt at bringing the Apollo 13 mission to the screen was met with widespread criticism, especially from those involved in the real mission. How did this first film, a soap opera-style adaptation, differ so greatly from the dramatic reality of Apollo 13, and why did it take so long for the astronauts’ true story to be told?
The Real Mission: A Fight for Survival
The Apollo 13 mission was intended to be NASA’s third crewed lunar landing, but it turned into a desperate struggle for survival when an oxygen tank exploded two days into the mission. The explosion destroyed the spacecraft’s power and life support systems, forcing the astronauts to abandon their plans to land on the moon. With temperatures plummeting, oxygen running low, and carbon dioxide levels rising, the crew had no choice but to rely on their training, resourcefulness, and the ground control team’s expertise to make it back to Earth.
In the days that followed, millions of people around the world were riveted to news coverage of the rescue. Family members, including Jim Lovell’s wife, Marilyn, anxiously watched from Earth as the astronauts faced life-threatening challenges. As the days passed, and with help from the Manned Spacecraft Center in Houston, the astronauts’ survival was ensured. NASA engineers and flight directors worked around the clock, providing crucial assistance to build a makeshift CO2 filter from a sock, duct tape, and cardboard—a moment that highlighted the collaboration between the astronauts and the ground crew.
After a tense and harrowing four days, the astronauts safely splashed down in the South Pacific, where millions of viewers watched the world’s most dramatic space rescue unfold. President Richard Nixon later awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom to the mission control team, and the astronauts were hailed as heroes. However, the public’s understanding of the mission, as conveyed through film, was far from accurate.
The First Adaptation: A Fictionalized Soap Opera
In 1974, just four years after the Apollo 13 mission, the first movie adaptation was made. Houston, We’ve Got a Problem was released on ABC, but it bore little resemblance to the real events. Starring Robert Culp and Sandra Dee, this movie took the unusual approach of focusing on the workers at Mission Control rather than the astronauts themselves. While NASA allowed the filmmakers to use the Johnson Space Center facilities and even appear as extras, the agency made it clear that they would not be involved in the creative process.
This decision led to a film that added fictional elements in a way that distorted the real story. The movie explored the personal lives of the Mission Control team—such as a character’s heart condition and a custody dispute—issues that were entirely unrelated to the mission. Notably, the astronauts were barely featured in the film, and their experiences were relegated to the background.
Jim Lovell, upon reading the script, was appalled. He described the movie as a “disservice” to everyone involved in the Apollo 13 mission, stating that it falsely implied the real drama was happening in Mission Control rather than on the crippled spacecraft. Lovell went as far as to say that the story should have been based on a fictional space mission, rather than exploiting a real-life disaster for melodrama.
The Real Apollo 13: Ron Howard’s 1995 Adaptation
For years, Houston, We’ve Got a Problem stood as the sole film portrayal of the Apollo 13 mission, leaving many to wonder if the story would ever be accurately depicted. That changed in 1995 when Ron Howard’s Apollo 13 brought the true story of the mission to the big screen. This adaptation was rooted in the real events of the mission, drawing heavily from Jim Lovell’s autobiography Lost Moon: The Perilous Voyage of Apollo 13, which he co-wrote with journalist Jeffrey Kluger.
Lovell was actively involved in the making of Apollo 13, offering input on the script and even helping Tom Hanks prepare for the role of the astronaut. Hanks spent hours with Lovell, including a flight in Lovell’s personal plane, and also trained in NASA’s “Vomit Comet” to experience the weightlessness that astronauts endure. The film’s attention to detail, from the exact replicas of the Apollo spacecraft to the realistic portrayal of the astronauts’ harrowing experience, earned it critical acclaim.
Apollo 13 was a success both commercially and artistically, receiving nine Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture. It won two Oscars, for Best Film Editing and Best Sound. Lovell, who had been so disappointed by the previous adaptation, gave his full approval to Howard’s version, praising the filmmakers for accurately portraying the mission’s emotional and physical toll.
A New Era: Apollo 13: Survival on Netflix
Even after the success of Apollo 13, the real story of the mission continues to be explored, especially with the release of the new documentary Apollo 13: Survival on Netflix. Premiering in September 2024, this documentary provides an in-depth look at the mission’s raw emotions and personal stakes. The film includes archival footage, testimonies from those involved, and even home videos from the Lovell family, offering a fresh perspective on the harrowing experience.
Jim Lovell, now 96, has expressed his approval of the documentary, stating that it brought back vivid memories of the mission’s intensity. His son, Jeff Lovell, worked closely with the filmmakers to ensure a deeply personal and human narrative. The documentary aims to give viewers an even deeper connection to the people behind the mission, providing insight into what it was like for the astronauts, their families, and the ground crew during those terrifying days in space.
The Enduring Legacy of Apollo 13
From the dramatic and misleading Houston, We’ve Got a Problem to the emotionally resonant Apollo 13 and the latest documentary, the story of Apollo 13 continues to captivate audiences. It serves as a testament to the courage, ingenuity, and teamwork that defined one of the most remarkable rescue missions in history. Thanks to these various adaptations, the true legacy of Apollo 13 remains etched in the annals of space exploration for generations to come.
Leave a Reply